Is Bargersville Safe, Pros and cons of living in Bargersville

Bargersville, Indiana, offers a blend of suburban tranquility and community-focused living, making it an appealing destination for those seeking a change of pace. Situated in Johnson County, this town has experienced notable growth, attracting new residents with its family-friendly atmosphere and access to amenities. The community is characterized by a strong sense of local identity, with residents often engaging in town events and supporting local businesses.

The town’s development over the years has transformed it from a smaller settlement into a growing suburban area. This evolution has brought with it an increased demand for housing and services, while efforts are made to maintain the town’s inherent charm. Bargersville’s strategic location provides convenient access to larger urban centers, further enhancing its appeal to a diverse range of individuals and families.

Is it Safe to Live in Bargersville?

Bargersville is considered a safe community with crime rates significantly below the national average. The overall crime rate is approximately 77% lower than the national average per 100,000 residents (according to AreaVibes). Violent crimes in Bargersville are reported at a rate 83% lower than the national average (according to AreaVibes). Property crime rates also remain considerably lower than the national average, with 424 incidents per 100,000 people compared to the U.S. average of 1,760 (according to AreaVibes).

The Bargersville Police Department serves the community, and data from 2019-2024 indicates a low incidence of crime. Over this five-year period, the town recorded 117 violent crimes and no property crimes, with an average violent crime rate of 44.4 per 100,000 residents, which is 58.2% below the national average (according to the FBI Crime Data Explorer). These statistics suggest that residents can feel secure in their neighborhoods, with a low probability of becoming a victim of crime.

Housing and Cost of Living

The housing market in Bargersville presents a mix of opportunities for both buyers and renters, with a median listing price of $524.9K (according to Realtor.com® Research). The homeownership rate stands at a significant 73.3% (according to Data USA), indicating a preference for owning homes among residents. The median home value in Bargersville is approximately $442,137, showing an increase of 2.3% over the past year (according to Zillow).

For those considering renting, the median rent in Bargersville is $1,379 per month (according to Point2Homes). However, other sources indicate a higher average rent, with Zillow reporting an average rent of $2,695 and houses for rent ranging from $1,191 to $2,845. The rental market can be described as tight, with limited listings available relative to demand (according to Realtor.com® Research).

The overall cost of living in Bargersville is approximately 1% higher than the U.S. national average (according to Salary.com). This is driven by factors such as housing costs, transportation expenses, and food prices. For singles, the estimated monthly living cost is $2,497, while for a family of four, it is approximately $5,499 (according to Salary.com).

Job Market and Economy

Bargersville’s economy is supported by a workforce of approximately 5,039 residents, with the largest industries being Health Care & Social Assistance, Manufacturing, and Professional, Scientific, & Technical Services (according to Data USA). The average annual household income in Bargersville was $157,036 in 2024, though the median income stood at $114,231 (according to Point2Homes). The unemployment rate is not explicitly stated in the provided search results, but data suggests a growing employed population.

The highest-paying industries in Bargersville include Professional, Scientific, & Technical Services, Professional, Scientific, & Management, & Administrative & Waste Management Services, and Public Administration (according to Data USA). The average salary in Bargersville, as of May 2026, is reported as $22.03 per hour or $45,827 per year (according to ZipRecruiter). However, another source indicates an average annual salary of $83,941 for employees at Bargersville, with a range typically from $73,400 to $96,051 (according to another source). This discrepancy may reflect different methodologies or specific company data.

Climate and Weather

Bargersville experiences a climate with distinct seasons, characterized by warm summers and cold winters. Throughout the year, temperatures generally range from 18°F to 85°F (according to myPerfectWeather). The town receives an annual precipitation of about 46 inches, which includes rain and the liquid equivalent of snow, with an average of 19 inches of snowfall per year (according to myPerfectWeather).

Summers in Bargersville are typically long, warm, humid, and wet, with July being the hottest month, averaging highs of 85°F and lows of 65°F (according to myPerfectWeather and Wanderlog). Winters are short, very cold, snowy, and windy, with January seeing average highs of 36°F and lows of 19°F (according to myPerfectWeather and Wanderlog). The month with the most rainfall is May, with an average of 4.3 inches, while February receives the least at 1.9 inches (according to Wanderlog).

Education and Schools

The public schools in Bargersville are highly rated, contributing to the town’s appeal for families. The community is served by schools within the Center Grove Community School Corp and the Franklin Community School Corp. Schools in Bargersville have an average ranking of 10/10, placing them in the top 10% of Indiana public schools (according to Niche).

Bargersville public schools show strong performance in academic areas, with an average math proficiency score of 68% and a reading proficiency score of 59% (according to Niche). Top-ranked schools include Maple Grove Elementary School, Walnut Grove Elementary School, and Union Elementary School, all noted for their academic achievements (according to Niche and SchoolDigger.com). These schools serve students from kindergarten through 6th grade and are part of districts that consistently perform well within the state.

Demographics and Lifestyle

Bargersville is home to approximately 10,752 residents, with a projected population of 12,978 by 2026 (according to Point2Homes and US Census Bureau). The median age in Bargersville is 38.1 years (according to Point2Homes). The population is predominantly White, making up about 87.3% of residents, followed by Asian (5.1%) and Black or African American (3.2%) populations (according to US Census Bureau).

The town offers a sparse suburban feel, and most residents own their homes (according to Niche). Bargersville attracts many families and young professionals, with a significant portion of households being families (76.5% according to Point2Homes). The community tends to be conservative, and residents are generally well-educated, with a high percentage of adults holding a bachelor’s degree or higher (according to NeighborhoodScout).