Is Carrollwood Safe, Pros and cons of living in Carrollwood

Carrollwood, Florida, offers a blend of suburban tranquility and convenient access to urban amenities, making it an appealing choice for many. This unincorporated community, situated in Hillsborough County, is known for its well-established neighborhoods and family-friendly atmosphere. It provides a quieter pace of life while remaining close to the vibrant city of Tampa.

The area was originally developed as a planned residential community, and today it retains a sense of established charm. With a population of over 34,000 residents, Carrollwood is a significant suburban hub that balances residential living with access to essential services and recreational opportunities. Its location provides a gateway to the broader Tampa Bay region, enhancing its desirability for those seeking both community and connectivity.

Is it Safe to Live in Carrollwood?

Carrollwood is generally considered a safe place to live, with crime rates reported to be lower than the national average. According to AreaVibes, Carrollwood’s overall crime rate is 58% lower than the national average, and violent crimes are specifically 61% lower than the national average. This statistic suggests a low likelihood of experiencing crime in the area.

While specific FBI crime statistics for Carrollwood are not always reported, estimates suggest a favorable safety profile. The chance of becoming a victim of crime in Carrollwood is approximately 1 in 114. Year over year, crime in Carrollwood has shown a decrease of 7%. The northwest part of the neighborhood is often cited by residents as the safest area.

Crime Statistics Overview

The crime rate in Carrollwood is notably lower than both the national and state averages. Violent crime, a significant concern for many, is substantially reduced compared to national figures. Property crime also sees a considerable decrease, contributing to the overall sense of security for residents.

While most crime statistics are estimates, the general trend indicates a safe environment. The available data suggests that Carrollwood is safer than 72% of all other cities in Florida. This safety record is a key factor for individuals and families considering a move to the area.

Housing Costs in Carrollwood

The housing market in Carrollwood presents a mix of affordability and value, with a median home price that reflects its desirable location. The median sale price of a home in Carrollwood was approximately $384,000 as of last month, which is a slight decrease of 4.1% compared to the previous year. Homes in Carrollwood are also noted to be about 10% more expensive than the average for Florida.

For those considering renting, the average rent for an apartment in Carrollwood is around $1,712 per month. A one-bedroom apartment averages about $1,400, while a two-bedroom unit is closer to $1,773. Houses for rent tend to be more expensive, with an average monthly cost of $2,375. These figures suggest that while homeownership might be a significant investment, rental options are also available, albeit at a considerable price point.

Home Values and Trends

Carrollwood’s housing market is described as somewhat competitive. The median sale price per square foot is around $245, showing a slight decrease of 1.4% year-over-year. Homes in Carrollwood typically spend about 59 days on the market, which is longer than the previous year.

The median home value in Carrollwood is $384,600, which is higher than the national median of $332,700. Neighborhoods like Carrollwood Village tend to have higher median home prices, with one report indicating a median sale price of $460,000 in February 2026. Despite these figures, Carrollwood is often seen as offering a balance of affordability and affluence.

Rental Market Insights

The rental market in Carrollwood shows a median rent of $1,715, which is higher than the national median of $1,413. A significant portion of rentals, about 60%, fall between $1,501 and $2,000 per month. This indicates that while there are more budget-friendly options, the majority of rental properties are in the mid to upper-mid price range.

As of May 2026, the average apartment rent in Carrollwood is $1,152 for a studio, $1,370 for a one-bedroom, and $1,685 for a two-bedroom unit. Rent in Carrollwood has decreased by 2.6% over the past year. Renters make up about 32% of the population in Carrollwood.

Job Market and Employment in Carrollwood

Carrollwood’s job market is supported by its proximity to Tampa and a diverse range of industries within the broader Tampa Bay area. The average salary in Carrollwood is reported to be around $42,760 per year, or approximately $20.56 per hour. However, other sources suggest a higher median household income of $68,422, and a more recent estimate of $81,959 for median household income.

Wages in Carrollwood have been noted to be increasing, while the cost of living has seen a decrease, offering a positive economic outlook for residents. The most popular employers in the community include Wellcare Health Plans, Inc., Citibank, and the University of South Florida. These major employers contribute significantly to the local economy and provide a variety of employment opportunities.

Major Employers and Industries

The Tampa Bay area, which includes Carrollwood, has a robust economy with key industries such as defense and security, financial services, life sciences, and healthcare. Major employers in the wider region include MacDill Air Force Base, BayCare Health System, and the University of South Florida. Within Carrollwood itself, Wellcare Health Plans, Inc., Citibank, and the University of South Florida are identified as significant employers.

Other notable companies in the Tampa Bay area that may offer employment opportunities include Jabil, Raymond James, and The Mosaic Company. The presence of these large organizations indicates a strong and diverse job market, offering a range of positions from entry-level to executive roles.

Salaries and Wages

The average annual salary in Carrollwood is estimated at $42,760, with the 25th percentile earning around $30,349 and the 75th percentile earning up to $53,500. Some job titles in Carrollwood can command significantly higher salaries, such as Consultation Liaison Psychiatry, Bone Marrow Transplant Physician, and Vice President at Citibank.

The median household income in Carrollwood is reported differently across various sources, ranging from $62,266 (2011-2015) to $68,422 and $81,959. This variation may be due to different reporting periods and methodologies. The per capita income for the community was reported as $35,090.

Climate in Carrollwood

Carrollwood experiences a humid subtropical climate, characteristic of central Florida. Summers are typically hot and humid, with frequent afternoon thunderstorms. Winters are mild and generally dry, with occasional cool fronts bringing brief periods of colder weather.

The average high temperature in Carrollwood during the summer months can reach the high 80s to low 90s Fahrenheit. Winters see average highs in the 60s and 70s Fahrenheit. Rainfall is most abundant during the summer wet season, from June through September, while the drier season typically occurs from November through April.

Temperature and Rainfall

The climate in Carrollwood is influenced by its proximity to the Gulf of Mexico, which moderates temperatures and increases humidity. Average high temperatures in July and August often hover around 90°F (32°C), with overnight lows in the mid-70s°F (24°C). The winter months offer a pleasant reprieve, with average highs in the mid-60s°F (18°C) and lows in the 40s°F (4-9°C).

Annual rainfall in Carrollwood is substantial, typically exceeding 50 inches. The majority of this precipitation falls during the summer months due to convective thunderstorms. While hurricanes are a possibility in Florida, Carrollwood is somewhat inland, offering some protection compared to coastal areas.

Education in Carrollwood

Carrollwood is served by the Hillsborough County Public Schools district, which provides a range of educational options for residents. The public schools in Carrollwood are generally considered to be above average. Carrollwood Elementary School, for instance, has received an overall Niche grade of A-.

Carrollwood Elementary School serves students from pre-kindergarten through 8th grade and has a student-teacher ratio of 13 to 1. State test scores indicate that approximately 70% of students are proficient in math and 63% in reading. The school is also recognized for its diversity, ranking among the most diverse public K-8 schools in Florida.

Public School Performance

Public schools in Carrollwood are highly rated, with several recognized for their academic performance and diversity. Carrollwood Elementary School is noted for its strong academic standing within Florida. The school district as a whole strives to provide quality education across all grade levels.

For secondary education, schools like Gaither High School and Tampa Bay Technical High School serve the broader Carrollwood area and are recognized within the state for their offerings. These institutions provide students with pathways to higher education and career readiness.

Private School Options

In addition to public schools, Carrollwood also offers private educational institutions. Carrollwood Day School, for example, is a highly-rated private school offering education from pre-kindergarten through 12th grade. It has received an A+ rating from Niche and is known for its rigorous academics, including the International Baccalaureate (IB) program.

The school emphasizes character development alongside academics, aiming to foster well-rounded students. Parents often praise the school’s strong leadership, dedicated teachers, and supportive community environment. Carrollwood Day School also provides comprehensive college counseling services to prepare students for higher education.

Demographics of Carrollwood

Carrollwood is a diverse suburb with a population of over 34,000 residents. The median age in Carrollwood is 43.5 years, which is slightly higher than the Florida average. This median age suggests a community with a significant number of established families and older residents.

The racial composition of Carrollwood is fairly diverse. Caucasian individuals make up approximately 52% of the population, while Hispanic residents constitute about 34%. There are also smaller Black and Asian communities, representing 7% and 4% of the population, respectively.

Population and Age Distribution

As of the 2020 census, Carrollwood had a population of 34,352. The population density is approximately 3,500 people per square mile. The age distribution shows that 18.4% of residents are under 18, and 20.1% are 65 or older. This indicates a balanced age demographic with a substantial proportion of both younger and older residents.

The gender ratio in Carrollwood is approximately 52% female and 48% male. For every 100 females, there are about 90.5 males. This slight skew towards a female population is common in many suburban areas.

Income and Economic Diversity

The median household income in Carrollwood is reported to be around $68,422, which is about 25% higher than the average household income for the state of Florida. More recent estimates place the median household income higher, at $81,959. The poverty rate in Carrollwood is approximately 8.36%.

Carrollwood’s economy is supported by a range of employment opportunities, with average salaries varying by occupation. The community’s economic diversity is further reflected in its income levels, which are generally higher than the state average, suggesting a stable economic environment for its residents.

Pros and Cons of Living in Carrollwood

Carrollwood offers a desirable living environment with numerous advantages, including a strong sense of community and convenient access to amenities. Residents often praise the area for its family-friendly atmosphere, ample green spaces, and proximity to shopping and dining options. The community’s well-maintained parks and public spaces contribute to a high quality of life.

The area’s safety is a significant draw, with crime rates reported to be well below national averages. This peaceful environment is appealing to families and individuals seeking a secure place to call home. Furthermore, the public schools serving Carrollwood are generally well-regarded, adding to its appeal for those with children.

Advantages of Carrollwood

One of the primary advantages of living in Carrollwood is its blend of suburban quietude and urban accessibility. It offers a peaceful residential setting while being a short drive from the cultural and economic hub of Tampa. The community is known for its beautiful parks and recreational facilities, providing ample opportunities for outdoor activities.

The housing market, while competitive, offers a range of options, and the overall cost of living is considered reasonable for the region. The presence of good schools and a low crime rate further enhances its attractiveness as a place to live and raise a family.

Challenges of Carrollwood

Despite its many benefits, Carrollwood does present some challenges for potential residents. While generally safe, some areas may experience higher rates of specific crimes, such as theft. Additionally, some residents have noted that certain neighborhoods within Carrollwood may have issues with discrimination.

The cost of living, particularly housing, can be a consideration. While often seen as affordable compared to some areas, the median home price is higher than the Florida average, and rental prices are also above the national median. Commuting can also be a factor, as traffic in the Tampa Bay area can be significant, though Carrollwood’s location offers reasonable access to major roadways.