Is North Amityville Safe, Pros and cons of living in North Amityville

North Amityville, a hamlet in Suffolk County, New York, presents a complex profile for potential residents. It is a diverse community with a significant population of Black or African American and Hispanic residents. The area offers a dense suburban feel, with a majority of residents owning their homes. Public schools in North Amityville are considered above average, contributing to its appeal for families.

The community is part of the larger New York metropolitan area, influencing its cost of living and job market. Understanding the nuances of North Amityville requires a detailed look at its safety, economic landscape, and daily living conditions.

Is it Safe to Live in North Amityville?

North Amityville’s overall crime rate is estimated to be 85% above the national average as of 2026 (DoorProfit). Residents face a chance of approximately 1 in 203 of being a victim of violent crime annually and a 1 in 24 chance for property crime (DoorProfit). The estimated violent crime rate is 491.5 per 100,000 residents, which is 29% higher than the national average (DoorProfit). Murder rates are particularly high, at 9.8 per 100,000, which is 97% above the national average (DoorProfit).

Property crime is also a significant concern, with an estimated rate of 4,194.4 per 100,000 residents, 129% higher than the national average (DoorProfit). Larceny/theft is the most common crime, at 3,191.4 incidents per 100,000 residents, 128% above the national average (DoorProfit). While the overall crime rate is higher than the national average, safety can vary significantly by neighborhood within North Amityville (DoorProfit).

Housing and Cost of Living

The median home value in North Amityville was $466,500 in 2024, an increase of 3.19% from the previous year (Data USA). The homeownership rate stands at 63.5%, which is slightly lower than the national average (Data USA). Renters in North Amityville face an average monthly rent of $2,744 as of March 2026, representing a 2.66% increase from the prior year (RentCafe). The median rent for a one-bedroom apartment is $2,443, while two-bedroom units average $3,239 (RentCafe).

The cost of living in North Amityville is generally considered higher than the national average. For instance, the median rent of $2,744 per month is significantly higher than the national median rent of $1,413 (Niche). This higher cost of housing contributes to the overall cost of living in the area, which is often reflected in various expense categories.

Job Market and Economy

As of 2024, employment in North Amityville grew by 9.32%, with the number of employees increasing from 11.3k to 12.3k (Data USA). The most common employment sectors for residents are Health Care & Social Assistance, Retail Trade, and Manufacturing (Data USA). The average annual salary in North Amityville is approximately $60,349, with most salaries ranging between $46,097 and $72,771 (ZipRecruiter).

The median household income in North Amityville was $136,654 in 2024 (Data USA). This figure represents a growth from the previous year’s value of $125,991 (Data USA). The unemployment rate in North Amityville was 3.7% (Niche). Major employers in the broader Amityville area include Northwell Health, NAPCO Security Technologies, and Bellco Generics (Zippia).

Climate and Environment

North Amityville experiences a climate characterized by warm, humid summers and very cold, snowy, and windy winters (MyPerfectWeather). Temperatures typically range from 26°F to 82°F throughout the year, rarely dropping below 13°F or exceeding 90°F (MyPerfectWeather). The hottest month is July, with an average high of 82°F and a low of 68°F, while January is the coldest, with an average low of 27°F and a high of 39°F (MyPerfectWeather).

The area receives an annual precipitation of approximately 44 inches, with about 25 inches of snowfall (MyPerfectWeather). Wet days, defined as those with at least 0.04 inches of precipitation, occur most frequently in July, with an average of 9.8 days (MyPerfectWeather). The drier season typically spans from December to March, with October having the fewest wet days, averaging 7.5 (MyPerfectWeather).

Demographics and Diversity

North Amityville is home to approximately 21,138 residents, with a median age of 37.1 years (Data USA). The population is diverse, with Black or African American residents constituting the largest group, followed by Hispanic residents (Data USA). Specifically, 45.09% of the population is Black or African American, and 37.6% are Hispanic (Data USA). White residents make up 7.4% of the population, with Asian residents at 3.6% (Data USA).

Citizenship status shows that 85% of residents are U.S. citizens, which is lower than the national average (Data USA). Approximately 34.6% of residents were born outside the United States, a figure comparable to the national average (Data USA). The community is considered diverse, ranking highly among other places in New York for diversity (Niche).

Education

The public schools in North Amityville are rated as above average (Niche). The Farmingdale Union Free School District, which serves parts of North Amityville, holds a rating of B+ with 6 schools and 4,862 students (Niche). Lindenhurst Union Free School District also serves the area and has a rating of B- with 5 schools and 2,926 students (Niche).

Within the Amityville Union Free School District, Amityville Memorial High School has a student-teacher ratio of 11:1 and a graduation rate of 80% (Homes.com). Northeast Elementary School, located in North Amityville, is noted as a high-performing school with a Niche grade of B+ and a student-teacher ratio of 6:1 (Homes.com).